Art
CRITICS PAGE
Art Without Criticism
We initially created the Railing Opinion column in November 2004 as a platform for critics, art historians, and artists to voice insights and critical reflections on the nature of art, its history, and its relationship to current political and social currents. Due to the overwhelming response to the rotating guest editorship of the ARTSEEN section since February 2012 and inspired particularly by the thoughtful questions Irving Sandler posed to critics on the state of criticism in the December/January 2013 issue, we have revived and reimagined Railing Opinion as the Critics’ Page. Here we hope to foster dialogue that addresses and broadens the value of art criticism in today’s complex visual culture.
In 1831, a year after the July Revolution in France, Heinrich Heine wrote about the Paris Salon and the art he encountered there. Heine observed that the exhibited paintings were like “poor children of art, to whom a busy crowd tossed only the alms of an indifferent glance.” This did not imply that the public was not worthy or incapable of appreciating the paintings on display. To Heine, the visitors’ minds were “occupied elsewhere and filled with anxious politics.” Even though he praised some of the paintings in the Salon, the main reason why many other works failed to attract any attention from the public (and Heine the critic) had to do with a lack of “art in enthusiastic harmony with [its] age, an art that does not need to borrow its symbols from a faded past.”
Heinrich Heine does nothing less than question an entire generation of artists’ vision for art. Furthermore, he questions the Salon itself as a place that promotes art that has, in large parts, become irrelevant. It is a shame that one has to travel back to a time when the phrase “institutional critique” had not yet been invented to realize that one of the gains of the great revolutions and their democratizing effects was to be able to challenge the conditions of your time, to not accept them as a given.
In his most recent contribution for the Brooklyn Rail Irving Sandler arrives at the following conclusion about the state of art criticism in our time: “During the pluralistic postmodernist era there are no longer riveting polemics that absorb critics. Instead, critics tend to be reduced to choosing artists they admire (and in rare cases, dislike) and deal with each individually. Art world discourse has become unfocused and undramatic, and has fallen into a kind of disarray, and in the minds of many, irrelevant.”
If you take Sandler’s observation seriously, which I do, then you have to conclude that art criticism is in much worse shape than it was during Heine’s time. Art fairs and the art they exhibit and inevitably produce has been accepted as a given. Many art blogs and art publications write about art as if it existed independently of the art markets, art schools, art galleries, and institutions. Have we become lazy, have we become partially blind? How did we arrive at this laissez-faire art discourse that is not actually a discourse, but an unending series of opinions, comments, and naked praise?
Contributor
Viktor WitkowskiBorn in Poland, VIKTOR WITKOWSKI lived in Germany, France, and the U.S. before moving to Vermont where he teaches, makes, and writes about art. www.viktorwitkowski.com. http://sameoldart.tumblr.com/.
RECOMMENDED ARTICLES

Larry Poons: "First Thought, Best Thought"—The Particle Paintings (1996-2002)
By David RhodesDEC 19-JAN 20 | ArtSeen
They are somewhat akin to drawings by children: unfussy, direct, energized, inventive. The paintings are strikingly bold. Configurations of disjunctive color and pattern dont so much settle as insist on taking the viewer for yet another go around. Somehow this is never finished; the viewer is caught in a process, not of resolution but of constant change.

You Say You Want a Revolution: Remembering the 60s
By Colin KinniburghJUL-AUG 2018 | ArtSeen
At first glance the New York Public Library’s (NYPL) You Say You Want a Revolution: Remembering the 60s offers a familiar picture of that turbulent decade.

Routine Pleasures: Termite Art and the Paintings of Manny Farber
By Sean NamFEB 2019 | Film
Reputations can be fickle things, but in the case of Manny Farber there is no reason to believe that posterity will ever see fit to revise his standing as one of the most original film critics that this nation has ever produced. Whether or not he deserves a similar ranking as a painter is a question that viewers can answer for themselves thanks to an exhibition of his paintings that opened last fall at the Museum of Contemporary Art, Los Angeles.
Enghelab Street, A Revolution through Books: Iran 1979 – 1983
By Carol NisarDEC 19-JAN 20 | Art Books
Amassed by the artist Hannah Darabi, this oversized photobook casts a broadly curated lens on the sociopolitical turmoil induced by Irans Islamic revolution through a look at the Tehrans underground publishing scene. Including personal recollections, first-hand accounts from publishers and photographers, and invaluable photographic documentation of the books and the city, Darabi and researcher Chowra Makaremi reconstruct this important moment in Irans history.