We stand in solidarity with the uprising unfolding across the country following the murders of George Floyd, Breonna Taylor, Tony McDade, Nina Pop, Jamel Floyd, and those affected by generations of structural violence against Black communities.

We're putting together a list of resources for self-education, mutual aid, and ongoing action in the struggle for racial justice.

The Brooklyn Rail

DEC 12-JAN 13

All Issues
DEC 12-JAN 13 Issue

The Persistence of Art Criticism

Criticism is autobiography; we can only write from what we know, and are. The dancer cannot dissemble, claimed Graham. Much less the critic. Though he or she can be namby-pamby, noncommittal, or sloppy. These sins are to be avoided.
Criticism responds to what is done by artists. The highest form is to be a sweeper-up after the artist has left the studio to go to the bar downstairs. Frank O’Hara: “Irving Sandler continues to be the balayeur des artistes / and so do I (sometimes I think I’m ‘in love’ with painting).” The critic doesn’t tell the artist what to do; the critic has the privilege of analyzing what the artist has done.

On the other hand, artists, in their work, are also critics—and critics do play a role in deciding what should or should not be regarded as essential.

The best critics are often practitioners (artists or poets): Elaine de Kooning, Fairfield Porter, Edwin Denby, Merlin James. But some, like Sanford Schwartz, are pure critics. A good critic changes the way you see the world.

Much blogging is superficial. Most important, in any endeavor, is a group that shares enthusiasm, though not necessarily tastes. Venues—in print, on line, or in person—still carry the most weight. As Pound advised Creeley when the latter wanted to start a journal—get some people to do it with.

The art world still discusses avidly what prominent critics have written, and therefore that writing continues to play a vital role. (Though I should cite Merlin James’s excellent essay “The Non-Existence of Art Criticism.”)

It would be great to have a magazine that did not rely on ads.


Vincent Katz

VINCENT KATZ is a poet, translator, and critic. He is the editor of Black Mountain College: Experiment In Art (MIT Press), which will receive a second printing in 2013. He has done collaborative books with, among others, Rudy Burckhardt, Wayne Gonzales, and Matthias Mansen.


The Brooklyn Rail

DEC 12-JAN 13

All Issues