Editor's Message From The Editor
WATCH THE CLOSING DOORS
Reading a book called The History of White People on the subway is a disorienting experience. Each time I look up, I encounter a spectrum of skin colors, from pasty winter white to deep African black—with numerous shades in between. Nell Irvin Painter’s insightful new book may remind us that in reality, there is no such thing as racial difference. But as I glance around the N train, it’s hard to avoid seeing distinctions in hue without thinking that they reveal something innate about each person; such a habit of mind is ingrained in American culture (and we are by no means exceptional). It’s even more troubling that in 2010, Brooklyn remains so residentially segregated that one can likely guess pretty accurately where each person lives. As to the question of whether Obamaland can become a post-racial society, color me a skeptic.
Painter’s approach brings forth the strengths and weaknesses of old-fashioned intellectual history. In assessing how leading thinkers from antiquity through the present created dubious racial hierarchies, Painter creates a coherent narrative based around innumerable incoherent ideas. There’s more than a bit of dark humor to be found in the writings of figures such as the German philosopher Johann Gottfried von Herder (1744-1803), who once insisted that Turks (by which he was referring to Persians) were “originally a hideous race, [but they] improved their appearance, and rendered themselves more agreeable, when handsomer nations became servants to them.” Painter seems to take particular delight in detailing the many idiotic racial observations of Ralph Waldo Emerson, still a towering giant in American thought. Like Jefferson before him, Emerson worshipped the Saxon “race,” at one point maintaining that as opposed to the innate “despotism” of the Normans, the “Saxon seed carries an instinct for liberty.” As history all-too frequently reminds us, yesterday’s windbag will be tomorrow’s laughingstock.
How much the leading thinkers of any era represent popularly held views is another story. Long before mass education and mass culture, those considered “white” in America held very clear ideas about their alleged superiority. And the books from which those ideas sprang were full of statutes, not intellectual inquiry. I could go on at length about how in the aftermath of Bacon’s Rebellion of 1676, Virginia elites created legal separation of blacks and whites—see the classic works of Winthrop D. Jordan (White Over Black) and Edmund S. Morgan (American Slavery, American Freedom). But I’ve reached my stop, and I’m sure to get back on the subway another day.
RECOMMENDED ARTICLES

Colored People Time: Quotidian Pasts
By Devin MaloneJUL-AUG 2019 | ArtSeen
A group of white sculptures sit atop glistening aluminum pedestals. To the right, two TV screens flash images of dancers, ritual objects, and footage from a post-war game show. An adjacent wall has been painted green to mimic the palette of a natural history museum and bears a single photograph.

Bahia Shehab and Haytham Nawar’s A History of Arab Graphic Design
By N.A. MansourAPRIL 2021 | Art Books
Easily the best introduction to the history of modern Arab visual culture on the market today, this new book lacks the jargon of exhibition catalogues, leans heavily on visual sources, and dismisses some previously held assumptions about Arab art.
Music: A Subversive History
By George GrellaNOV 2019 | Music
Songs about fucking and killingthat would have also been an appropriate subtitle for this scintillating new book from Ted Gioia. Hes already written three valuable books about the place of music in society and human experience, Healing Songs (2006), Works Songs (2006), and Love Songs: The Hidden history (2015). Music: A Subversive History builds on those by digging down into the fundamental nature of music, how it is made and how it affects us.
Kent Monkman: mistikôsiwak (Wooden Boat People)
By Ann C. CollinsFEB 2020 | ArtSeen
It may be that history, as Winston Churchill said, is written by the victors, but a deep satisfaction can be had for those who redraft it. Cree artist Kent Monkman does just that for the Metropolitan Museum of Arts inaugural Great Hall Commission. Monkman reverses the European gaze, presenting Indigenous people as heroes who welcome and rescue invading newcomers.